Calcium for everyone?
A 62-year-old asks if she should take a 1200 mg calcium pill daily 'for her bones.' She drinks 2 cups of milk and eats yogurt daily.
Replacing what's missing, and the surprising harm of population-wide supplementation.
If your iron is low, treating it makes a big difference. Magnesium can help some kinds of migraines and constipation. Most adults don't need extra calcium pills if they eat dairy or fortified foods — and high doses haven't reduced fractures in studies.
Iron: oral first (alternate day if intolerant); IV for malabsorption, intolerance, CKD, ongoing loss. Calcium: food-first; supplement to reach 1000–1200 mg/d total only when dietary inadequate. Magnesium glycinate or citrate for migraine prophylaxis (400 mg/d) — modest evidence.
Hepcidin rises after a single iron dose, blocking absorption for 24 h — biological basis for alternate-day dosing (Stoffel, Lancet Haematology 2017).
Minerals: clear deficiency-rescue benefit; population supplementation often null or harmful.
WHI and meta-analyses (Bolland 2010) suggest no fracture benefit and possible CV signal; dietary calcium preferred.
Short patient encounters that test your judgment, not your recall. Pick the most defensible response, then reveal the rationale and a sample coaching script you could actually say at the bedside.
A 62-year-old asks if she should take a 1200 mg calcium pill daily 'for her bones.' She drinks 2 cups of milk and eats yogurt daily.